THE town of Bogale was bustling and colourful at the end of last
month, but the reality of the six-month anniversary of cyclone
Nargis in the Ayeyarwady delta was just a boat ride away.
A two-and-a-half-hour float downriver brought me to Shwe Pyi
Aye, a village that lost half its inhabitants to the cyclone.
When the storm hit, many of the residents took shelter in what
were deemed to be the two strongest structures in the village:
the school and the monastery.
Sixty people made it to the monastery. The 11-foot tidal surge
reached the second level of the building and the wind tore the
roof away, but the people huddled inside survived.
During my visit the monastery still stood in the middle of the
village, like a beacon of strength and security in an unstable
world. The roof consisted of tarpaulin sheets donated by the UN
Development Programme (UNDP) and the precincts were kept clean.
It had become the site of an important monthly ritual for villagers.
“We hold a ceremony at the monastery on the second day
of every month as a remembrance for the deceased,” said
villager Kyaw Lin. “We need alms to complete repairs of
the building but right now nobody can give alms.”
The school building did not fare so well in the storm.
“The school collapsed on the people who sheltered there,”
one villager told me when I visited a canvas tent set up by UNICEF
as a temporary school, adjacent to the stark metal frames marking
the old school’s location.
The tent now hosts classes for 110 children from grades 1 through
7.
According to the Department of Social Welfare, only 74 of the
1407 schools damaged in the delta have received funding to be
rebuilt, although various agencies have supported the reopening
of more than 2500 closed schools.
As for the rest of the village, residents said that every house
was destroyed during the cyclone, every family lost at least one
member and everyone lost their livelihoods.
It was a week before assistance arrived at Shwe Pyi Aye. Like
thousands of others throughout the delta, they survived on coconut
milk and soiled rice while they waited.
When government boats finally came to the village, it was to
collect those who wanted to move to camps in the town of Bogale.
Many of the women took up
the offer, joining the droves that filled Bogale’s schools
and monasteries in the aftermath of the destruction.
I had visited Bogale before, only four days after cyclone Nargis.
The town seemed colourless at the time, the people’s movements
slow, as if they had not yet adjusted to life in the post-Nargis
world.
But Bogale was different during my return visit in October.
The camps had been dismantled and the vibrant town was filled
with the sounds of reconstruction.
Shwe Pyi Aye had also changed in the previous six months, although
the village still had a long way to go before life would return
to normal for its residents.
“Things are much better than directly after the cyclone.
There’s no comparison,” one resident told me.
The distance that villagers have travelled since the storm is
typified by the story of 65-year-old U Kyin Maung. His eyes clouded
over for a moment when he told he lost all eight of his family
members on the night of May 2-3.
Since then he has rebuilt his house, which does double duty
as a small shop that he was able to revive with a K40,000 grant
from UNDP. He also said he is still getting food aid donated by
the World Food Program (WFP) and distributed by World Vision.
U Kyin Maung is one of 114,102 people in 250 villages who have
benefited from UNDP’s basic services package assistance,
which has included grants for rebuilding destroyed houses, daily
wages for community work and the establishment of self-reliance
groups for women.
Depending on funding, UNDP hopes to expand the project to 500
more villages in the coming months. They also hope to restart
their microfinance project, which could mean writing off as much
as US$3 million in loans taken out by 50,000 borrowers living
in cyclone-affected areas.
But one UNHCR worker said that many people are concerned about
taking out loans at present because they cannot foresee being
able to pay the money back anytime soon. In this situation, UNDP
recognises that grants are more appropriate.
U Kyin Maung’s grant helped him take over the shop his
adult child operated before the cyclone.
“Every week I invest my profits into expanding the business,”
said U Kyin Maung. The shelves held bottles of orange soda, small
packets of nuts, a few bottles of medicine, all brought by boat
from Bogale. The most expensive item was K50.
He said he made about K500 a day, enough to survive on along
with the food aid he received, but not enough to invest in improving
the strength of his house in preparation for next year’s
monsoon season.
Other residents of Shwe Pyi Aye said they were also concerned
about water supplies. As in past years, natural supplies are expected
to dwindle during the dry season from December to March. Normally,
villagers overcome the shortfall by buying water from sellers.
“We also don’t know if the people who usually sell
water from up the river will be able to bring water down to our
village,” said one local resident.
And while many men have been able to find work as farmhands
and day labourers, for women the story is often different.
Myo Myo, a widow who lives in Thet Kae Aaeik village, explained:
“Men are paid as day labourers for the whole season, while
women are only paid by the day.”
While many livelihood programs run by aid organisations are targeting
the agricultural sector, this does not necessarily ensure that
the most vulnerable people get adequate support, said Liz Pender,
a UNFPA gender specialist.
“In times of desperation, it comes down to self-preservation.
Socially, men are in positions where they can leave their children
with their wives or daughters, so they will get preference for
daily labour and do not have to worry about things like their
physical safety,” she said. “They can leave the village
to access work that is unavailable to women.”
“We are women. What else is there for us to do?”
asked Su Mon, a widow who runs a shop along with a household that
is now entirely made up of women.
“We are very grateful for everything that has been given
to us. It’s just that we need to be able to stand up on
our own now, and to do that we need some more help,” said
another villager, Khin Suu.
NGOs and UN agencies seem all too aware of the gaps, an awareness
that is manifested in calls for additional funding. UNDP has asked
for more than $52 million for an early recovery program slated
to last for 12 more months. So far it has received less than $20
million of this amount.
Other agencies face similar shortfalls. The UN’s Myanmar
Flash Appeal 2008 has attracted only 55 percent of the needed
funding, while a number of smaller NGOs are wondering whether
they will be able to continue working once the emergency funding
promised through January runs out.
Whether or not the money is actually there, the need for it
will remain.