 |
|
Dr Chan Aye gives a check-up to a child
in a Karen village in the Bago Yoma near Taungoo.
Pic: Douglas Long |
THIRTEEN years ago, Dr Tin Thein took a small group of foreign
tourists into the mountains west of Taungoo. They were interested
in seeing Myanma Timber Enterprise elephants clearing trees in
the Bago Yoma, and he had the local connections to make it happen.
This was 1995 – Taungoo had barely reopened to tourists
after years of insurgency. The “Visit Myanmar Year”
and subsequent tourism boycott campaign were at least 12 months
away. The number of annual visitors to the country was still in
the tens of thousands.
But Dr Tin Thein saw a future in the elephant camp trips –
and a way help the poor communities who work in the timber industry.
His son, Dr Chan Aye, now runs what should be considered one
of the bright spots in a tourism industry that has recently been
battered by one disaster after another.
It is success built on the small stream of foreign independent
travellers who come to Myanmar each year and stray off the Yangon-Inle-Mandalay-Bagan
path.
Many are after more from their Myanmar experience than pagodas
and picturesque lakes and, increasingly, are looking to ecotourism
to fill the gap.
It’s not surprising that Taungoo is a popular choice.
While many of Myanmar’s ecotourism sites are in difficult-to-reach
places and require government permission, Taungoo is located just
a few hundred kilometres north of Yangon, with easy road and rail
connections. The elephant camp tours are also reasonably priced,
at US$170 for one person, $100 for two and $80 for three people.
Dr Chan Aye is hesitant to call his elephant camp tours ecotourism,
a term that had barely been coined when Dr Tin Thein started the
business. He seems – like many – unsure of the exact
meaning.
But, in practice, it is the best kind of ecotourism, with minimal
environ-mental impact and financial benefits and employment for
local people.
At the most simple level, watching the elephants work is an
amazing sight. The logs, several metres in diameter, weigh well
over a tonne (1000 kilograms), with one end tapered so the log
doesn’t catch on the forest floor. Several holes are cut
so a chain can be looped and attached to the elephant’s
harness and then, with some coaxing from the oosie (also known
as the mahout) and his assistant, the pet chate, the elephant
drags the log.
It’s not an easy task, even for an elephant. The 27-year-old
male in front of us is visibly struggling, dropping to its knees
as the strength drains from its legs and letting slip low roars
of exertion.
Finally, after 30 minutes, the teak log is laid to rest beside
about 20 others. This is where elephants show their versatility;
they are surprisingly agile and can easily manoeuvre the valuable
timber with their trunk.
Dr Chan Aye’s tours are also thought-provoking and touch
on several environmental issues in Myanmar. The country is home
to the largest number of domesticated or captive elephants in
the world, and the process of capturing them from the wild is
dangerous for both humans and the elephant.
“Breaking” wild elephants is particularly difficult
and cruel; the elephants are left for days without food or water
until they stop struggling and are slowly coaxed “back to
life”, as Dr Chan Aye puts it, by trainers who stroke the
elephants while singing traditional songs. It is not uncommon
for elephants to die while being broken.
The timber extraction is also difficult and tiring work, and
elephants have been known to drop dead while working, the oosie
says.
But, while it’s physically punishing, the work doesn’t
seem to be cruel and the life expectancy of a working elephant
is generally higher than their counterparts both in the wild and
in zoos.
Because of the elephants’ value, they are kept healthy
and well-fed, working until early afternoon to avoid the heat
with every third day off. At night, the elephants are free to
roam in the jungle and are rounded up each morning by the oosie.
Myanmar’s oosies are “without doubt … the
best trained and most skilled mahouts in the world”, according
to a report by NGO EleAid, which also calls Myanmar a “world
leader” in veterinary knowledge and care of elephants.
Timber extraction in Myanmar is also a contentious issue but
it is argued that by restricting logging to the confines of the
Myanmar Selection Strategy (MSS), and using elephants to extract
the timber, the effects on the environment are minimised.
In the 2006 EleAid report, author Charles Begley concluded that
government timber policy could provide a “stable platform
on which to build a world class conservation policy” that
could protect wild elephants and their habitat.
“[The government] could also use extensive natural areas
and an enlightened environmental policy to build a major ecotourism
industry. The income from such a business could match or even
surpass that of timber exports,” Mr Begley said.
But for now real ecotourism is practised by just a few tourism
operators in Myanmar, mostly small operations like Dr Chan Aye’s.
“Recently I have been taking out groups of foreigners
about five days a week,” he says, as we career along the
Taungoo-Pyay road that crosses the Bago Yoma.
The dust the vehicle kicks up from the road is so pervasive
we have to wear face masks, and the trees beside the road are
coated in a thin layer of orange powder.
About halfway back to Taungoo we stop at a small school. About
50 students, in the familiar green longyi and white shirt, are
crammed into the single-room building.
Dr Chan Aye hauls over a bag that has been sitting in the back
of our pickup truck all day – it’s full of books and
pencils for the children, who show their gratitude by singing
a couple of English-language songs for us.
It is just one small example of how tourism can improve the
well-being of local people. There are also economic benefits,
such as employment, and Dr Chan Aye provides free medical assistance
to people living in the area.